Wednesday, May 9, 2012

Superfund Sites Lab


Superfund Sites Lab Project

     Many sites used for numerous reasons years ago still stand in unsafe conditions affecting our land and ground water depended on by many people for drinking. Below you can find examples and pictures of the areas that I researched. Some have been cleaned up and are being monitored regularly for toxins to surface in the soil while others are still fighting the battle to even start the clean up process. These are only a few of thousands of abandoned sites that need attention across the United States.   
     The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) was established in 1970 by President Nixon to enforce laws in the coming years that were created to protect the environment. As the population grew and industrial technology progressed, toxic waste and pollution of several kinds continued to become a harmful issue. Major companies were disposing of toxins and hazardous waste in unsafe ways that were not only damaging to the earth, but created detrimental health problems as well.
     The EPA enforces the environmental policies created to protect the environment and public health. Many of these policies were designed years ago to stop or regulate things such as unnecessary amounts of harmful pollution emitted into the air and water we depend on. It is because of these laws that many bodies of water have been restored to public fisheries, but if not closely monitored, they can easily fall back to useless and dangerous waste water areas.
     The Superfund Act of 1980, also known as the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (CERCLA). The goal of this act is to clean up and restore abandoned, hazardous sites such as gas stations and chemical plants. The fund’s for clean up come from taxing chemical waste producers. Anyone with relation to the site will be held responsible for costs but successfully retrieving all costs incurred isn’t always likely since remediation costs range from $370 billion to $1.7 trillion. Currently the EPA estimates over 47,000 sites need cleaned up while 1,600 sites were listed on the National Priorities List and over 1,000 clean ups have been successfully completed.

WASAU Ground Water Contamination

     A site in Wausau, Wisconsin that was responsible for providing water to approximately 35,000 people was found in 1982 to be contaminated with high levels of volatile organic compounds (VOC). In 1988 the EPA signed off on an interim record of decision (ROD) to address this area of contamination and remediation began. By 1990 the groundwater contamination system was complete. In 1991 soil vapor extractions (SVE) systems were began and completed by 1994 at both source sites. Source of contamination #1 was an old municipal landfill south of City Well 6 on the Marathon Electric Property and found to be contaminated with trichloroethlyene(TCE)  . The second source was in the Wausau Chemical Facility Property southwest of City Well 3 and found to be contaminated with tetrachloroethelyene(PCE), TCE, and VOC’s.
     Both site remediation’s were complete by 1996. Reviews are being conducted every 5 years to ensure the protection of human health and the environment. The last inspection of this site took place in June 2010 and the next inspection is scheduled to be conducted in March 2015. Costs involved have been paid for by responsible parties and continues to be addressed through federal, state, and potentially responsible parties. 
http://www.marketplacelists.com/remediation/images/sve_system_2.jpg (5/9/12)
Volatile Organic Compound Effects http://oecotextiles.files.wordpress.com/2010/03/smog.jpgm (5/9/12)


Davis Timber Company
     In 1972 the Davis Timber Company began a timber processing and wood preserving operation in Hattiesburg, Lamar County, Mississippi and continued their business through the late 1980’s.  An onsite storage pond contained pentachlorophenol, dioxin, and furan contaminates from waste water discharged by the plant during operations. This pond was reported to have been capped off and backfilled in 1980. Country Club Lake reported several fish killings between 1974 and 1987. This lake is located one mile away from the timber facility catching its runoff water contaminants along with Mineral Creeks. In 1989 a warning was issued to residents against consuming fish caught in these waters due to the levels of dioxins found in the fish tissue.
     In 2000 the Davis Timber site was added to the National Priorities List and the Remedial Investigation (RI) process began immediately following. Although the process began right away, findings weren’t complete until 2006 and a proposed plan wasn’t expected to be complete until September 2009. The clean up was expected to start in 2011 and anticipated to take approximately 14 months, but still hasn’t began. The warning against consumption of fish was lifted in 2001 due to the decrease in dioxin levels found in the fish tissue.
http://legeros.com/hidden-raleigh/images/map-country-club-lake.jpg (5/9/12)


Furan (5/9/12) http://www.chemeng.drexel.edu/palmesegroup/research/peterson/amy1.jpg

Alabama Army Ammunition Plant
     Located in Talladega County Alabama in approximately 5170 acres of land rested an ammunition plant for the United States Army from 1941-1945. About 45 miles south east of Birmingham and 4 miles north of Childersburg on Plant Road along side of Highway 235, this large piece of land was divided into two sections. Area A consisting of 2714 acres was the former storage and General Service Administration (GSA) region that is still controlled by the U.S. government. Area B consists of 2187 acres and was the former manufacturing (industrial) region of the plant. Contaminants were found in sediments, soils, debris, ground water, and residuals and were that of explosive material including DNT, TNT, and tetryl.
     Area A is currently being used as a wildlife preserve and a logging area by a private owner who purchased the property in 1991. Complete clean up of area A was finished by 1998. Area B has not been cleared of ground water contaminations but a proposal for cleanup of soils was submitted in 2008. It is hoped that the future of this area will include recreational and natural habitat.
Ammunition Plant http://www.stillman.ws/shffld2.jpg (5/9/12)

Iron King Mine/Humboldt Smelter Superfund Sites (IKMHSSS)

     The IKMHSSS consists of 153 acres in Dewey-Humboldt, Yavapai County Arizona and was an active mine from 1906-1969 and was expanded in 1936 for mining of other minerals. The Smelter plant of Humboldt operated off and on from the late 1800’s to the early 1960’s.  This area contains soils and ground water contaminated with lead, arsenic, ore, and other minerals that test about allowance for safe drinking water in surrounding residential wells as well. The cause for contamination comes from the massive mine tailings and smelter ash covering thousands of acres of land. Fourteen Potentially Responsible Parties (PRP) have been notified but are not listed. Only four residential yards have been cleaned up at this point but compost was piled on Iron King tailings and soil sealant on the Humboldt Smelter ash piles to prevent the spread of dust contaminations. A plan to clean up the entire site was hope to have been completed by 2011 and implemented between 2012-2015.
     Photostabilization is proposed to be used in the IKMHSSS area during remediation and testing on plants have already been conducted. Plants chosen were based on visual examination, USDA guidelines for plant habitats, and to represent trees, shrubs, and grasses for a variety of plant canopy and rooting depths. Plants decided upon after testing to uphold higher sustainability for this particular area were: Buffalo grass, mesquite, quailbush, and catclaw acacia. Adding compost to the soil can help increase the pH level by increasing the water-hold capacity increasing overall better soil structure and nutrients. When 10% compost was added to the species the buffalo grass responded the most to growth with the least amount of compost. The following is the grams dry weight for each species:
*Fescue & Catclaw= .5
*Mountain Mahogany & Mesquite= 1
*Quailbrush= 1.5
*Buffalo Grass= 4

Neutrophilic heterotrophic bacterial counts indicate an important portion of the community that is required for normal carbon and nutrient cycling processes within soil. The neutrophilic heterotrophic counts were very low, 670 bacteria per gram dry tailings at time zero with 0% compost. After 60 days of plant growth, the presence of plants with associated root activities further increases heterotrophs to 6.4x10(7) bacteria per gram dry tailings at both the 15% and 20% compost levels. It appears that 15% compost is the minimum required in order to diminish the toxicity of the tailings and support germination and plant growth.        
https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEjJxMZu3FmvACFJntWYJ-lToBPAFcJQ3xCr-bJTUGBZT3cNQFL8_Gmc6pPe5jmN9NieesTeEvv01FZ_aiIHLglGryjJxO0H6YmtyWtNsHHJxKrQyQdSA092LY3yoMKcVaxoPDWYizt5c8HQ/s400/Iron+King+Mine+-+Humboldt+Smelter+EPA.jpg
Iron King Mine-http://mountelliotremediationproject.com/yahoo_site_admin/assets/images/m227pc.276112036_large.jpg (5/9/12) 
Humboldt Smelter- http://www.sharlot.org/img/wm_images/m218pd.jpg (5/9/12)

Tuesday, May 8, 2012

Unit 4


Unit 4 Compilation

Chapter 12: Energy
*Case Study
*Energy Resources & Issues
*Fossil Fuels
*Energy Conservation
Chapter 8: Environmental Health
*Case Study
*Environmental Health
*Toxicology
*Movement, Distribution, & Fate of Toxins
Chapter 15: Environmental Policy & Sustainability
*Case Study
*Environmental Policy & Law
*Major Environmental Laws
*How Are Policies Made?
*International Policies
*What Can Individuals Do?


Chapter 12: Energy

*Case Study: Mining A Tropical Paradise
      
     What was once known as a luxurious tropical island filled with green life from coast to coast is now devastated with un-inhabitable environment from stress induced drought. The island of Nauru was turned upside down from mining, and even worse it was mining for a phosphate sold to foreign countries for use as a rich fertilizer. In the process of mining, the vegetation was destroyed leaving only rock in its place. Without necessary vegetation, the natural hydrologic cycle could not continue and the rain clouds were slowly chased away.
     The riches the fertilizer brought the islanders had severe consequences. The island not only suffers environmental devastation, but the well being of the islanders is at great risk as well. Obesity, diabetes, and cardiovascular disease plague the people while forcing them to find a new place to continue their lives. As drought continues to cause hardship and the resources run out, the islanders are forced to relocate. Hoping their investments in the mining will help them to purchase another island knowing they will never find one as beautiful as their homeland. It is questioned whether or not the people deserve the help from their surrounding countries in finding and relocating to another island? Although they made a mistake, should they really have to suffer the rest of their lives for it? This should be seen as an example for a lesson learned to all of what the world could turn into if action against unnecessary mining, while implementing environmentally friendly ways of life does not take priority.    
:http://everydaysaholiday.org/nauru-independence-day/ (5/8/12)
   

*Energy Resources & Uses
     The majority of our energy supply has been dependent on heat since the beginning of the Neolithic Era approximately 10,000 years ago. As technology progressed, the world became dependent on fossil fuels (derived from natural resources including organic waste) to produce energy. New resources of dependable energy have been developed, such as solar panels and wind turbines that create energy from renewable resources like the sun and wind. These energy creating tools do not cause damage to the atmosphere like the smoke from burning coal, which currently provides 88% of our energy.
     Our future as well as our children’s depends on changing our energy production. The developing country of China (who has contributed a large amount of pollution to the environment from commercial industrial production and improper regulations) has made a huge step towards dependence on renewable energy. China currently has over 40 million roof top solar panels and they are increasing that number every day! Not only do our energy resources require us to change to continue sustainable life on earth, our incredible amount of wasted energy needs to be reduced as well. In the U.S. alone we consume one quarter of the fossil fuel produced in the entire world and only 7% of our energy supply is produced from renewable energy sources! One of our biggest battles with foreign countries, and our highest cost to most citizens, comes from oil, but this does not stop the average American from using approximately 60 barrels of oil every year! We do not have to sacrifice our luxuries necessarily to protect our environment either, just substitute our resources to be more efficient. There are many countries that have higher standards of living than the U.S. and still only consume half as much energy as we do!
     We use a lot of natural resources just to transport our resources for production as well. Although transportation of natural resources by ships, trains, and barges account for only 12% or less of our transportation fuel, it’s still unnecessary pollution emitted into the environment. Energy used to make electricity is considered a “clean” source of energy because it doesn’t emit any pollution and almost all of its energy is put to useful work. 
http://cdn.asia.cnet.com/i/r/2009/crave/gt/63011659/solartiles_440x287.jpg (5/8/2012)


*Fossil Fuels     
     Coal mining is a huge industry in the United States and employs many American’s with a good paying, benefits included, DANGEROUS job! Coal not only provides a large percentage of our energy, it also provides environmentally and medically hazardous pollution to the air we breathe. Although coal mining can be beneficial to our energy supply and most likely keep us going for thousands of years, the damage it is doing is far more hazardous than it’s worth. There are different types of mining but each come with risks. Underground coal miners are at risk for black lung disease, explosion, or complete cave in of the entire mine. The alternative is mountain top removal where they do exactly as it sounds and remove the tops of mountains layer by layer in search of coal created by decomposed organisms from hundreds of millions of years ago. This form of mining is cheaper and safer to humans but causes huge controversy over the devastation it leaves behind on its surrounding environment. Large gaping holes where coal was derived is a left open and resolutions to stop mountain top removal have only been partially successful.
     Other technology has created a way to produce energy from coal without actually burning it. This process known as Integrated Gasification Combined Cycle (IGCC) is more complex and costly but a successful plant outside Tampa Florida currently converts 2,400 tons of coal into enough energy to power 100,000 homes on a daily basis. Over a period of time the costs involved wash out and profit can be made. Since there still aren’t laws enforcing IGCC plants, Tampa is the only one in the U.S. and only a few more are planned to be built out of the 80 total power plants in construction. People focus on where they can make more money, not necessarily what’s better for the environment and the IGCC plant construction costs 15%-20% more to build than the others.
     As the economy and individuals become more dependent on oil, availability becomes scarce and prices rise dramatically. In 1993 a barrel of oil could be purchased for $15, as of 2008 barrels of oil were purchased at the unbelievable rate of $150 each! Oil dependency not only hurts the environment but it devastates economies as well. When this happens people begin to turn to alternative energy sources but once given a break on barrel costs, many people immediately return to their wasteful ways again.
     Oil derived in the U.S. is only enough to fuel our current lifestyle for about 4 years. Therefore this oil is held on reserve for emergency and oil is bought from outside the country. It’s a dirty job and other countries do not always appreciate fueling our bad habits at the expense of damaging their environment. Currently Canada is our largest producer of oil from their tar sands. Oil shales are similar to tar sands as they both heat the kerogen to liquid then pump it out like crude oil. Although oil shales are in layers of sedimentary rock found in abundance in Utah, Colorado, and Wyoming, if an efficient way isn’t created to derive this organic material the outcome could be devastating to the surrounding environment.
     A growing industry of 2.2% per year is in energy found in natural gas. This industry can be produced here in the U.S. in more abundance than crude oil, but can be just as damaging to the environment. So the government found a way to have shipments of liquefied gas brought over from other areas such as parts of the Middle East and Russia. The danger of these shipments is the risk of explosion. One ship’s explosion would have the effect of a medium size atomic bomb and therefore finding cities willing to except these shipments can be very difficult.
http://www.cartoonmovement.com/depot/cartoons/2010/12/KBMD9GJTSP2HFoLHNpPmMw.jpg (5/8/12)


*Energy Conservation   
     Our biggest hope in reducing oil emissions is to cut back on energy wasted. A good majority of emissions of air pollutants comes from motor vehicles. The production of more efficient transportation has come a long way. You can now purchase a car that can get 72 mpg highway as opposed to the average 13 mpg found in vehicles in the 1970’s. The Obama administration also to a large step towards protecting our environment by requiring all cars and light trucks produced to have an average fleet fuel efficiency of 35.5 mpg by 2016. It is estimated that raising fuel efficiency just 1 mpg on all light truck and cars could save around 295,000 bbl of oil consumed per day!
     Efficient insulation on houses and timers on appliances are just a couple ways to save a lot of energy. You can purchase windows that are comparable to a 4” thick insulated wall. Timers on appliances, such as hot water heaters, saves energy by only allowing the appliance to run during off peak hours (which is usually after 9 p.m. and before 9 a.m.) when less people are using energy or less production of energy is needed. You can also have remote settings in which you have the ability to control these settings from a distance, such as your cell phone. This would allow you to leave the air conditioning off during hours which you are not home but turn it back on within reasonable time before you return so it has time to cool down or heat up your house. A new invention in test right now called smart metering was designed to relay how much energy a particular appliance utilizes and the costs incurred during different times of the day. This could make people more aware of their waste and help them to conserve more energy. Even though the energy intensity (or amount of energy required to provide certain services or goods) has declined, costs to provide the energy continue to rise the more we depend on and waste natural resources.
http://www.rapsample.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/06/Smart-Car.jpg (5/8/12)



Chapter 8: Environmental Health & Toxicolgy

Case Study: Environmental Estrogens
     In 1980 a lake in Florida suffered a DDT spill that caused a disruption in sex hormones found by side effects apparent in their alligators. From low levels of testosterone and shrunken penises in males to abnormal ovaries and high levels of estrogen in females, the alligator population was dropping at a tremendous rate. Pesticide-laden run off from a nearby farm as well contributed to high levels of a persistent breakdown of DDT referred to as DDE found in all alligators that were tested with abnormal sex hormones.
     The alarming question to answer now is, could this be the explanation for sex hormone abnormalities in humans? Being humans are at the top of the food chain, it is inevitable we will come in contact with these chemicals through consumption of these animals. Scientists are having a difficult time proving it but continue to research the relation this could have with human development problems and cancer in sexual reproductive organs.     
http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/nature/gallery/alligators.html (5/8/12)


Environmental Health
     Apparently we are all ill to some extent according to the World Health Organization (WHO) that defines health as not only being absent of disease or infirmity, but being in a “state of complete physical, mental, and social well being.” So then someone who is “unsocial” would then be “unhealthy” and so on. The majority of the population views someone who is carrying a virus or bound by a disease causing impairment to be unhealthy and they do not always consider the impairments of mental and social well being. Environmental health focuses on the factors that cause morbidity (illness) and mortality (death) from the world we reside, such as:
*Toxins (chemicals & smoking)
*Radiation (UV Rays & Ionizing)
*Pollution (water & air)
*Infectious Agents (virus & bacteria protozoa)
*Trauma (accidents)
    
     What wasn’t accounted for until recently is the years of life lost to a disability. Most people do not consider being paralyzed to a wheel chair from a car accident as “living”. Disability adjusted life years (DALY’s) is a “health measure that assess the total burden of a disease by combining pre-mature deaths and loss of a healthy life that result from illness or disability.” Diseases that once were only of major concern in the wealthier countries such as cancer or cardiovascular disease due to poor diet are now becoming an epidemic in poorer countries as they continue to develop and adopt the poor eating habits of others. It is predicted that by 2020 global cancer rates will increase by 50% leaving 15 million people to suffer from this disease and 9 million of them to die from it. WHO also foresees heart disease sky rocketing from the 5th leading cause of death to the number 1 leading cause of death!
     As developing countries continue to adopt our bad habits, another one has recently become of concern worldwide and that is depression. This epidemic is expected to become the 2nd largest cause of all years lived with a disability worldwide. Another number expected to jump from 11th place to 5th place is obstructive living diseases such as lung cancer, emphysema, and asthma from the growing number of tobacco users worldwide. This along with obesity will be the contributors to the top 5 causes of death (other than traffic accidents) including heart disease, depression, and stroke, by the year 2020.
     The spread of disease is done through pathogens such as viruses and bacteria. Pathogens as well known as influenza and food borne illnesses can take many forms in which some of those the body can fight off with only mild to severe side effects while others may take thousands of lives. With each new treatment comes its pros and cons. Some diseases such as smallpox and polio have become unheard of, while others such as tuberculosis are building a resistance to antibiotics and becoming even stronger. Some disease can emerge (emergent diseases) again after 20 or more years without any cases. New diseases such as West Nile virus and H1N1 are also considered emergent diseases and prove how fast diseases can spread and take lives. The most common epidemic of disease is HIV/AIDS spreading at an alarming rate while taking an unbelievable amount of lives in the process.      
     Another way to spread to disease known as ecological diseases is done through animals and livestock. This can not only cause drastic population reduction of species, but also the disease and death of humans. This can be especially dangerous when carried around by migrating birds or in animals consumed by humans.
     Both diseases can be spread in different ways but they’ve both been proven to be more susceptible in stressful environments that humans cause such as deforestation and cross country travel. Since we do not predict a near future of these practices coming to a halt, science has started testing of other approaches referred to as conservation medicine. This is an attempt to study how these ways affect our health in various forms. This will hopefully help with future epidemics and outbreaks.
     As doctors continue to prescribe unnecessary or incorrect antibiotics and patients continue to not finish full prescriptions of necessary antibiotics because they “feel better”, resistant Methicillan Staphylococcus Aureus (MRSA) grows and diseases become stronger. It is estimated that at least 50 million antibiotic prescriptions written in the Unites States alone are either unnecessary or not even the right type of antibiotic to treat that particular illness. Ranchers who confine animals in large amounts are constantly feeding animals (such as poultry, hogs, and cattle) large amounts of steroid hormones and antibiotics to prevent any type of pathogens from destroying/killing their “paychecks”. Once again these antibiotics are unnecessary and when urinated out, they continue to spread in small amounts allowing pathogens to build stronger resistance to them.
     While people in the U.S. over-use and abuse the privilege of having antibiotics at their disposal, people in developing countries continue to spread vicious yet treatable diseases such as HIV and parasitic diseases killing hundreds of thousands of people every year! While around 600,000 infants acquire HIV every year in developing countries from their mother, people in the U.S. worry about how to treat their bald spots! Although Melinda and Bill Gates have contributed $200 million from their own foundation to aid in medical treatments for developing countries, the U.S. can only seem to donate .12cents per every $100 from GDP to help this cause. If apparently people dying from treatable diseases can’t find priority on our countries agenda, a selfish way they could think of it is those diseases can easily spread through traveling tourists and end up on the door handle of their next rental car or in the hospital they are sent to for routine check-ups such as mammograms, cardio testing, etc. While we have the luxury of preventable maintenance through annual check-ups, many people in developing countries are considered lucky to live to 30 years of age!
http://www.slvhealth.org/images/EarthDayPicture2010.jpg (5/8/12)


Toxicology 
     Toxicology is the study of poisons (toxics). There is a long list of toxics and sadly we come in contact with more than one of them on a daily basis! One common mistake made is the correlation between toxic material and hazardous material. Although they can both be equally as dangerous, not all hazardous material is toxic. Materials can be labeled hazardous for many other reasons such as being flammable or explosive.
     Toxins can be grouped into several different categories such as teratogens which are specified to cause abnormalities during embryonic growth and development. Some of these toxins are not intentional but some are and many are preventable such as cigarette smoke being inhaled by the mother either directly or indirectly. Another example would be the consumption of alcoholic beverages during pregnancy which can cause fetal alcohol syndrome. Fetal alcohol syndrome can be dangerous to mental and behavioral development, physical craniofacial abnormalities, and even death of the fetus.
     Other toxins include neurotoxins that invade the nervous system killing or damaging nerve cells that are necessary for the entire nervous system to function appropriately. Carcinogens cause out of control cell growth resulting in malignant tumors, also known as cancer. Cancer is currently the second highest cause of death in the U.S. and with more than 200 million living in high areas of carcinogenic pollution, the number of cancer patients is bound to rise. Carcinogens as well as mutagens, are high risk chemicals to unborn children. Radiation is a well known mutagen that mutates DNA and can cause minor to severe birth defects. This will sound familiar if you’ve ever been into any x-ray, MRI, or CT room and the technician has asked you or someone you’re with if there’s any possibility anyone in the room is pregnant. Some chemicals can cause sexual dysfunction to sex hormones. These chemicals, referred to as endocrine hormone disrupters, can interfere with normal growth, development, and physiology causing adverse side effects such as reproductive issues in females or feminization in males.
     Your body is trained to react to foreign objects such as allergens and antigens. These substances stimulate white blood cell counts to increase as an immune system response to protect the body. These responses can stimulate warnings known as sick building syndrome. Many of these symptoms are found to be caused by poorly vented indoor air contaminated by molds, carbon monoxide, and other toxic chemicals. Poor indoor ventilation not only causes higher energy production estimated at $60 billion per year, it creates the release of toxic chemicals found in insulation, carpet, building material, plastics, and many other household objects.

http://alcoholdetoxadvise.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/Fetal-Alcohol-Syndrome-Characteristics.jpg (5/8/12)

Movement, Distribution, & Fate of Toxins
     Chemicals can travel in many different ways and can have different effects on each individual species. Pollution is obviously the biggest risk to being exposed to deadly chemicals and is estimated to kill approximately 3 million people every year. Some people may not realize they’ve been exposed while others who are already ill and weak, or children that are young and still developing, are more at risk for serious or even fatal side effects.
     There are two different ways for chemicals to dissolve, by oil or by water. Those that dissolve by oil will settle into the fatty lipids in our bodies where they can’t be broken down and will continue to wreak havoc on our body. While cells are supposed to absorb essential nutrients and minerals, those same cells may trap harmful substances. The process of absorbing and storing molecules is called bioaccumulation. Biomagnification is when species on a higher trophic level consumes toxins that have been accumulated through the food chain. As toxins build and continue to pass, through consumption by their predators, species at the top of the food chain can suffer the adverse side effects to their health. A well known example of this would be the release of mercury into the air from burning coal. This contamination has caused 44 states to issue warnings against eating fish from their lakes due to the high exposure mercury and the adverse health risks this entails.
     Persistent organic pollutants are found in many more parts of our lives than just by consumption of fish. A few examples are upholstery cleaners such as Scotchgard, some non-stick pans such as Teflon, PVC piping used in the construction of many buildings, many plastics used for food storage, and it can even be traced to toys that our children put in their mouths on a daily basis! While some states and countries have made movement in banning the use and production of some of these chemicals, we’re nowhere near close to removing these common chemicals from daily contact. 
http://kanat.jsc.vsc.edu/student/shephear/popsmigration.bmp (5/8/12)
   

Chapter 15: Environmental Policy & Sustainability

Case Study: Is NEPA an Impediment?

     The National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) of 1970 was an effort to protect the environment by requiring an Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) for any major federal project that could have an impact on the environment. The reason for implementing the EIS procedure was to force agencies to publicly announce their plan of destruction, giving the opportunity for citizens to state their opinions and in turn the embarrassment caused would cause most agencies to reconsider their decisions or proposals.
     NEPA doesn’t forbid environmentally destructive activities as long as they comply with all other laws and many agencies are taking advantage of this loop hole. Two examples would be the “Healthy Forest Initiative” which involved logging of forests without an ESI so citizens couldn’t appeal, and the proposal of 77,000 coal-bed wells stating that the aquifer depletion and water pollution with this technology didn’t require review. Is this law more harmful than it is useful? 
http://www.fs.fed.us/projects/hfi/resources/images/future.jpg (5/8/12)


Environmental Policy & Law
     In order to have structure, we create policies and laws to be enforced. Laws are made by the government to form boundaries and consequences for unlawful actions. Policies can be made anywhere from work environments, to school environments and even in your own home, it’s just another way to say this is how things will be done and if they are not done this way, than this is what will happen.
     Policies and laws are formed by people with power and influence. Governmental officials can be influenced by groups who are passionate about making a change. Once a proposal is agreed upon then it is submitted to legislation where changes will be made on both sides until everyone gets their “way” on the bill and it is passed.
     Bills have been passed many times that make tremendous change, and then their importance diminishes with time and they aren’t enforced as they should be. The EPA enforces the environmental policy created to protect the environment and public health. Many of these policies were designed years ago to stop or regulate things such as unnecessary amounts of harmful pollution emitted into the air and water we depend on. It is because of these laws that many bodies of water have been restored to public fisheries, but if not closely monitored, they can easily fall back to useless and dangerous waste water areas.
     Everything that is done in our government is weighed by pros and cons and each side will have to take some cons that please the opposing party in order to seek what they see as beneficial in the bill. This is also called cost-benefit analysis. What’s most important in the ending result is that the benefits outweigh the costs and this can be enforced effectively and fairly. Coming to an agreement between opposing parties can be very difficult. Convincing others the change is necessary because current laws are not enough can be can be challenging when they do not understand the severity of damage that will occur if the laws are not changed or new policies are not made and enforced. As times change, laws and policies will need to change as well to meet the needs of our society and environment.     
http://i.i.com.com/cnwk.1d/i/tim/2010/11/19/pollution-000002804125XSmal_540x405.jpg (5/8/12)



Major Environmental Laws
     President Nixon took a huge step in cleaning up the environment by creating laws to enforce proper disposal of waste and air pollutions. The Clean Air Act (CAA) of 1970 regulates emissions of pollutions into the air by identifying, monitoring, and reducing air contaminants. The following is a list of the seven regulated criteria or conventional pollutants:
*Sulfur oxide
*Lead
*Carbon monoxide
*Nitrogen oxides
*Particulates (dust)
*Volatile organic compounds
*Metals & halogens (mercury or bromine compounds)

     The Clean Water Act (CWA) of 1972 does the following:
*Establishes rules for regulating discharges of pollutants into water
*Charges the EPA with establishing and regulating standards for water quality
*Makes it illegal to pollute navigable waters from a point source (such as a discharge pipe) without a permit. (page 372)
 The process begins with identifying sources of water pollutants. Once identified, regular monitoring of control point source pollutions is necessary. End-of Pipe discharge allows for rational discharge of low risk contaminants and must be apprehended prior to discharge. The EPA currently monitors over 4,000 water sheds and reports that 90% of all river miles and 87% of assessed lake acres monitored have met their goal of being “fishable and swimmable”.
     The Endangered Species Act (ESA) of 1973 was designed to protect vulnerable, threatened, or endangered species and their habitat. By 2010 the list of threatened or endangered species included 1216 animals and 753 plants. The ESA encounters much disagreement and creates crossfire with land developers. To compromise the ESA works with home owners’ lender agreements to conserve the habitat and home owners can even receive tax credits for cooperation.
     The Superfund Act of 1980 (as previously mentioned in chapter 13) is also known as the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (CERCLA). The goal of this act is to clean abandoned, hazardous sites such as gas stations and chemical plants, funds for clean up come from taxing chemical waste producers. Anyone with relation to the site will be held responsible for costs but successfully retrieving all costs incurred isn’t always likely since remediation costs range from $370 billion to $1.7 trillion. Currently the EPA estimates over 47,000 sites need cleaned up while 1,600 sites were listed on the National Priorities List and over 1,000 clean ups have been successfully completed.
     The National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) of 1969 was created t oversee these acts by enforcement and partnership with many other countries to be successful. They have 3 significant responsibilities:
*Establishes the Council on Environmental Quality (CEQ), the oversight board for general environmental conditions
*Directs federal agencies to take environmental consequences into account in decision making
*Requires that an Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) be published for every federal project that is likely to have an important effect on environmental quality.

Unfortunately this doesn’t stop all destructive activities to the environment but it does challenge the developer to a public announcement of their plans which then causes awareness and rebuttal. In their EIS they must include:
*Purpose and need for the project
*Alternatives to the proposed action (including taking no action)
*A statement of positive and negative environmental impacts of the proposed activities .
 If their EIS sounds humiliating on paper then most agencies aren’t likely to proceed. If they’re willing to, then once publicly announced organizations against the development will raise awareness with the negative impacts the development will cause in attempt to stop their proposal.
http://media.portland.indymedia.org/images/2003/05/264979.png (5/8/12)


How Are Policies Made?
     All laws can be enforced on different levels such as local state, country, and even national laws. All laws start with a proposal which can be initiated by an individual, group organization, or even just a petition signed by a bunch of random people who happen to agree on a particular change. Once the group is established and letters or petitions are organized, the proposal is submitted to your local representative in legislation. Personal letters and even phone calls can be very effective as well. When hearings are set, appearance helps keep you up to date and shows you are serious on where you stand. Once a federal law (statute) is agreed upon in congress, it is then signed by the Chief Executive (President) and becomes an official law.
     The responsibility of the judicial branch is to:
*Interpret what the precise meaning of a law is
*Decide whether or not a law was broken
*Decide whether or not a law violates the Constitution.

They oversee the cases of criminal and civil law, also known as case law. Civil cases are based upon disputes between individuals and corporations that do not result in time spent behind bars. Examples would be property rights, injury, or personal freedom. Criminal cases can result in either fines, jail time, or both. Examples of criminal offenses would be theft, violations of environmental law, or murder. If someone wants to dispute the legitimacy of a law and the Constitution then the case is then turned over to the Supreme Court for interpretation.
     The Executive Branch oversees environmental rules and policies headed by over 100 federal agencies as well as thousands of state and local boards and commissions. This includes NEPA, EPA, Department of Interior (U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service) and Department of Agriculture (Forest & Grassland). The EPA is headed by someone appointed by the President, employs over 18,000 people and takes the majority of responsibility for protecting the environment. This branch is responsible for all administrative law by setting rules, deciding disputes, and investigating misconduct. 
http://indextothesupremecourtoftexas.com/index_image2941.jpg (5/8/12)


International Policies
     The logic behind having international policies is that no one country can protect and provide all of their resources used, but with trade and treaties (convention) everyone works together to be successful. When the first Conference on Human Environment was held 40 years ago several nongovernmental organizations and representatives from 113 countries were in attendance. 20 years later that meeting turned into several DOZEN nongovernmental organizations with over 110 participating NATIONS! As more people become involved, conventions become more promptly enforced.Iin the last 25 years over 170 conventions and treaties have been negotiated to preserve our environment globally.
     Some of the most important collaborates include:
*Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species (CITES, 1973)
States that wild flora and fauna are an irreplaceable part of nature for scientific, cultural, aesthetical, economical, and recreational purposes. Exploitation through international trade amongst other human activity, threaten certain species and this agreement is to protect their existence.    
*Montreal Protocol (1987)
This is an agreement to take steps in depleting the use of certain chemicals damaging to our ozone layer. Without the ozone layer to shield the earth from the high U.V rays from the sun, life on earth would not exist. Chemicals such as chlorofluorocarbons (CFC’s) are being replaced with eco-friendly products and ever since, damage to the ozone layer has reduced noticeably.
*Basel Convention (1992)
This convention (enhanced in 1997) was created to protect undeveloped countries from the disposal of hazardous waste created by wealthier countries. The treaty states that each country is responsible for proper disposal of their own waste on their own land unless agreed upon, in writing, by authority of that country.
*UN Frameworks Convention on Climate Change (UNFCC 1994)
     This was created to share information on climate change between countries in hopes to reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. The Kyoto Protocol (1997) took it a step further by requiring signatories to reduce their GHG emissions to less than 1990 levels by 2012. China and the U.S. are the largest emitters of GHG and have not yet signed this treaty due to economic growth and fear of not being able to obtain these goals.
     Generally these agreements cannot be enforced by sending officials of one country into another country and forcing them to comply. Nations, countries, and states are motivated to comply because they have an image to uphold and actions damaging to the environment will be publicly announced which can have devastating effects on their economy in numerous ways. Although agreements are usually understood by all and signed by most, others may not comply and do not fear the consequences. A good example of this would be when the U.S banned any shipments into the country of blue fin tuna from China that was caught in a manner that killed dolphins, or shrimp from Mexico caught in a manner that killed sea turtles. Several countries fought back stating this movement was in non-compliance with the World Trade Organizations (WTO’s) international trade agreement and was represented as an illegal barrier to trade and therefore was put to a stop.
http://www.theamericanwrites.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/09/virtues-of-free-trade-image.jpeg (5/8/12)


What Can Individuals Do?
     Almost any aspect in life you take interest in can be used to contribute to the environment in a beneficial way. Reduce, Reuse, & Recycle (RRR) is the most beneficial move any individual can make no matter where they are. Using public transit or even your two good legs for transportation whenever possible contributes to the reduction of pollution. Author Edward Abbey once wrote:
“It is not enough to fight for the land; it is even more important to enjoy it. While it is still there. So get out there and mess around with your friends, ramble out yonder and explore the forest, encounter the grizz, climb the mountains. Run the rivers, breathe deep of that yet sweet and lucid air, it quietly for awhile and contemplate the precious stillness, that lovely mysterious and awesome place.” (page 379)

Thorstein Veblen created the term conspicuous consumption to define those who purchase things of no use to them only to portray an image to others, obviously contributing to unnecessary waste. Society feels a need to fulfill a psychological void by working harder to make more and more to buy more “stuff” which creates the hustle and bustle and takes away from the true meaning to life with family and friends and doing things we enjoy. Social critics have referred to this as an affluenza. If we simplified our lives with “necessities” as opposed to materialistic “wants” we would all be contributing to a happier life and healthier environment.
     Educating others on the environment and what we can do to help once we’ve been educated is crucial to the protection and sustainability of life on earth. Educators on environmental literacy range from: biology, chemistry, geology, ecology, climatology, geography, hydrology, and many others that are found as a paying career. Students and ordinary people can get involved in what’s called citizen science which involves working with real scientists to answer real scientific questions. There are many organizations and groups dedicated to science by volunteering in beneficial projects and research. “Former EPA administrator William K. Reilly said that environmental literacy is essential to both stewardship of our earth and to civic participation in general. Reilly argued that everyone needs some environmental literacy. It isn’t enough he said “for a few specialist to know what is going on while the rest of us wander about in ignorance.”      (page 380)  
http://solarxsarasota.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/05/Earth-Day.jpg (5/8/12)


-All quotations were cited from “Environmental Science Inquiry & Application”, Sixth Edition, Cunningham, William P., Cunningham, Mary Ann